You can choose between managed as well as unmanaged switches as per the requirements of your network. In this article, you will explain in detail the managed and unmanaged switches as well as point out the differences between them. Moreover, you will also get a guide on how to choose between these two switches for your network.
What Are Managed Switches?
A managed switch enables different Ethernet devices to communicate with each other. It allows the administrator to adjust the port and monitor the network. You can easily configure or manage the network and have great control over the accessibility of data. It allows you to configure it like trunks by setting a VLAN ID. A managed switch port can transport multiple VLAN frames on a single link. Administrators can even virtually combine different form ports for increasing the speed of the link. In a managed switch, you will find SNMP or Simple Network Management Protocol for monitoring the status of the switch ports. It can provide information on different switch ports like port status, traffic, and network errors. Not just that, it can even allow administrators to make various adjustments from different locations. A managed switch provides superior connectivity as well as functionality and enables easy access and control. When compared to an unmanaged switch, it offers higher quality. Designed to prioritize the network traffic, a managed switch helps in the consistency of network performance. It even allows administrators to have control over data sensitivity and offers maximum security.
What Are Unmanaged Switches?
An unmanaged switch comes in plug and play design and allows you to configure it through the IP switches or LED indicators. It does not require any complex setup. Unmanaged switches are great for few components or connecting edge devices. You can easily use it for home purposes, and it comes at a relatively low cost compared to the managed switches. An unmanaged switch does not offer monitoring operations, management, or remote configuration. Just like a managed switch, even the unmanaged switch can allow Ethernet devices to communicate with each other. However, it comes with a fixed configuration and eliminates the need for prioritizing the packets. One of the drawbacks of an unmanaged switch is that it does not support Internet Group Management Protocol (IGMP). This makes it unsuitable for industrial settings. On the contrary, an unmanaged switch also does not require configuration changes. It maintains MAC or media access control address table for the port collision domain. A port collision is a network boundary that can send a broadcast frame for reaching all the devices within the segment.
Managed vs Unmanaged Switch: Difference Table?
The Differences Between Managed and Unmanaged Switch
Here is a detailed list of the differences between the two switches.
Features
The main difference between the two switches lies in their features. An unmanaged switch is quite basic as far as its features go. On the contrary, a managed switch is simply feature-rich. Unmanaged switch basically allows control of ethernet devices with simple but fixed configurations. On the contrary, a managed switch allows the technician to customize the entire configuration as per the requirements of the network as well as the business. A managed switch also allows adding temporary systems to the network, while an unmanaged switch does not have any such provision. A managed switch allows the technician to not just configure but also monitor all the necessary network parameters as well as manage settings such as prioritizing channels, creating virtual LANs, channeling traffic, and much more. Moreover, with a managed switch, one can recover data in case there is a network failure.
Performance
An unmanaged switch is quite flawless in its performance, and it does what it needs to do. Unmanaged switches can maintain the MAC address table for reducing the number of transmitted broadcasts. Most importantly, it is very easy to set up as it has plug and play configuration. On the contrary, a managed switch is complicated in its setup, and therefore, there is a need for a network technician and even a networking team. A managed switch helps the team to configure properly to handle the network traffic separately as per requirement. Its performance is also flawless, but if the configuration is not perfect, there could be some performance issues.
Security
Unmanaged switches are less secured in comparison to managed switches. One of the main reasons why organizations opt for managed switches is due to the security features they offer. It is needless to say that for a commercial organization, security is one of the main priorities. Some of the common yet advanced security features that a managed switch can offer while an unmanaged switch lacks are 802.1 standard authentication, private VLANs, and port security. Moreover, there could be data protection and advanced encryption also available. These security features enable a managed switch to shut down any active threat to the network. However, the security features vary widely from one managed switch to another. On the contrary, unmanaged switches offer basic security that ensures that there are no apparent vulnerabilities in the network. For example, a lockable port cover ensures no physical tampering. Therefore, in comparison to managed switches, the security offered by unmanaged switches is negligible.
Application
Unmanaged switches find most applications in small businesses and organizations. This is because small businesses have a low budget and advanced security is not a big priority. By small businesses, we mean a company having a single office with limited systems to get access from the network. On the other hand, managed switches are suitable for commercial and enterprise businesses with huge networks. Naturally, there is a need for high-security measures as well as control over the traffic within the network which are possible only through managed switches.
Cost
Unmanaged switches are relatively cheaper than managed switches. The pricing of an unmanaged switch depends on the number of ports the switch has. On the contrary, managed switches are comparatively costlier. This is because there are additional features such as access controls and security measures that make the switch premium in pricing.
How To Choose Between A Managed and Unmanaged Network Switch –
Choosing between managed and unmanaged network switches completely depends upon user preferences. There are many factors that determine which one is suitable for you. Application: An unmanaged switch serves great for any startup business. It helps to reduce the cost of investments by cutting the cost of hiring a professional and getting expensive software. Managed switches do great for a large amount of data. It can tackle a growing network, and it lets you customize the settings as per requirements. Speed: Speed is another important factor that can differentiate between the two. A managed switch has improved speed compared to the unmanaged switch. Scalability: You should note that managed switches offer better scalability. You can manually configure it, and it can be great for growing networks or businesses. On the contrary, future scalability is not possible with unmanaged switches. Security: Managed switches offer better security than unmanaged switches. Managed switches work great for people who are looking to have maximum security with encryption, active threat disabling ability, preventing unauthorized access, and likewise. Control: If you are looking to have maximum flexibility, a managed switch is the right choice for you. You can configure bandwidth limit, tweak with network settings, set different protocols, and likewise. An unmanaged switch comes in the form of a plug-and-play switch that does not have any configuration.
Conclusion -Managed vs. Unmanaged Switches: Which is Right for You?
For small businesses or single office use, an unmanaged switch will work great. On the contrary, a large business enterprise must opt for a managed switch. If you have budget constraints, unmanaged switches are best for you. If security is your main priority, managed switches are perfect for you. If you have a dedicated team or professional person to handle the network, it has to be managed switches so that he can customize the settings and configure it as per requirements. Comment * Name * Email * Website
Δ
